I love getting their cheddar bagel toasted with butter. It doesn't need cream cheese because it's already a cheese bagel.
Their basil cream cheese is good, too, but I only order it on a plain toasted bagel.
Their smoked salmon bagels are dope, too. — Anonymous Reviewer
Sunday, December 27, 2020
I was recommended this place by a complete foodie, but, I ordered a French toast bagel (whaaaaa..?) with sausage egg and cheese. Mind blowing. Legit the best breakfast sandwich ever to grace this mouth. This place is dope! You won't regret going. Even with a 40 minute wait for the sandwich... I'd wait any day for it. — Anonymous Reviewer
Saturday, November 28, 2020
Awesome breakfast bagel sandwiches. Wonderful atmosphere. It has become a tradition for our family to visit Sclafani — Anonymous Reviewer
Friday, September 25, 2020
Pretty good but they slather WAY too much cream cheese on their bagel.
I would recommend ordering the lox bagel sandwich with only the cream cheese and smoked salmon instead of all the fixings. It's so much better without capers, onions and all that jazz. I order mine on a plain toastedbagel with plain cream cheese and double salmon, that's it. The magic formula. — Anonymous Reviewer
Sunday, August 16, 2020
First time ever coming here and I loved it! Everyone is friendly, the atmosphere is wonderful, and the food is delicious. Thank you!! — Anonymous Reviewer
Wednesday, May 13, 2020
You guys are an awesome sandwich stop, please please please advertise more on your car side takeout I haven't eaten here in over a month because you guys look closed down when I drive by — Anonymous Reviewer
Thursday, April 23, 2020
Just tried an assortment of the bagels and several cream cheeses. Divine. - the real deal! So glad they’re here in our food-deserty little town. — Anonymous Reviewer
Saturday, April 11, 2020
Great bagel sandwich! They offer car delivery. Stay safe! — Anonymous Reviewer
Friday, December 7, 2018
Great bagels and service. Great staff. One suggestion - add nurses/doctors to your 25% off for month of December. — Anonymous Reviewer